Fleck vs. GE Water Softeners
Fleck and GE water softeners are the two biggest names in the water-grading system industry. Both companies manufacture quality water softeners that perform effectively. However, to test which one among these two is the kingpin of performance, efficiency, and effectiveness, we decided to compare them side-by-side.
We took the two best water softeners of each brand and considered various parameters for their comparisons such as grain capacity, water flow rate, regeneration cycle, and water consumption.
The following sections cover the technical details and finally the verdict.
Fleck 5600 SXT Water Softener
All the models of Fleck and GE water softeners that we reviewed did an excellent job in softening water. However, considering the water consumption rate, water flow rate, grain capacity, and affordability, we have chosen the Fleck 5600 SXT 48,000 Grain capacity water softener as the best deal. Here are the reasons for it:
- It comes at a very affordable price
- A flow rate of 12 gallons per minute that can effectively serve a household with up to 6 members
- 8% crosslink for protection against chlorine ions
- Metered water regeneration technology for minimal water wastage
- Easy installation steps and a video tutorial USB drive
- Water test kit programming included in the packaging
- 5-year warranty on the control head and 10-year warranty on the tank
- Maintenance-free
Likewise, the runner up in our Fleck vs. GE water softeners review is the GE GXSH40V model. Most of the features in the GE GXSH40V are the same as those in the Fleck 5600 SXT. However, considering the flow rate, grain size filtering capacity and price, Fleck 5600 SXT is definitely the winner.
Quick Summary of Fleck vs. GE Water Softeners
| Product Image | Water Softeners Names | |
|---|---|---|
|
Best Affordable Water Softener for Household Use
Fleck 5600 SXT Water Softener
This is the best choice for a medium-sized household with up to 6 members. The system removes all the hardening minerals from your water to ensure soft water supply. Along with the Intelligent Regeneration technology, this water softener delivers efficient performance. |
View on Amazon |
|
High Capacity Water Softener with Twin Tanks
Fleck 9100 SXT Water Softener
This water softener is suitable for larger households with up to 4 bathrooms or even for commercial purposes. This system has the highest filtering capacity and flow rate in our review. Moreover, it has a twin tank for alternating water regeneration to supply soft water to your household without any interruption. |
View on Amazon |
|
Best Budget Water Softener for Small Households
GE GXSF30V Water Softener
This water softener is best suited for small households with up to three members. It is a budget-friendly system with meter-based regeneration technology to deliver optimum performance. |
View on Amazon |
|
Best Water Softener with Compact Design
GE GXSH40V Water Softener
This water softener is suitable for a household with up to five members. The SmartSoft technology ensures minimal water wastage. Moreover, the customizable settings feature makes it easy to install and operate the system. |
View on Amazon |
Fleck vs. GE Water Softeners - Compared and Reviewed
Fleck 5600 SXT Water Softener
Features Highlights
- Digital Display for monitoring the salt intake,
- Continuous performance for 72 hours,
- Safety Float,
- Intelligent water regeneration according to the need,
- Easy to install,
- Maintenance-free.
Product Specification
-
Dimensions:
27 x 17 x 62 inches
-
Weight:
20.8 pounds
-
Grain Capacities:
48,000
-
Flow Rate:
12 Gallons per minute
-
Water Consumption:
3 Gallons per minute
-
Voltage:
120 volts
-
Number of People:
Up to 6 people
Fleck 5600 SXT 48,000 Grain is one of the best water softeners in the market owing to its excellent performance and unique specifications. It comes with many useful features and high efficiency and thus can be a perfect choice for a household with up to six members.
Intelligent Regeneration
The 5600 SXT system tracks the amount of daily water consumption in the house. And based on the calculation, the system automatically changes its settings to match the water needs. Such a system makes sure your household is never without a good supply of soft water.
Safety Float
The safety float makes sure the device stays in place and eliminates the risk of water overflowing or spill. This helps in the efficient use of water with minimal wastage.
Digital Display
You can check the water softener performance status in the digital display. You can keep track of the water consumption rate, water regeneration time, or use it for troubleshooting. And you can modify the settings if you need to.
Effortless Installation
This product comes with a USB drive that includes video instructions on how to install a water softener. If you have a bit of experience in plumbing then you can easily install the product. You can hire a plumber if you face any difficulty in the installation step.
Maintenance-free
Using the 5600 SXT is very convenient and maintenance-free. You only need to do the salt refills every few months. The regeneration rate adjusts automatically according to water usage in the house, thanks to the metered-regeneration technology. You don’t even need to remember turning the device off, as it stops regenerating water if it is not in use.
Continuous Performance
In case there is a power cut, the control valve keeps the device running for 72 hours without interruption. A power failure will not change the settings of the water softener. In case of a power failure for more than 72 hours, you simply need to input the date and the system will program itself accordingly.
Pros
- Softens hard water of different grades
- Intelligent Regeneration technology
- Safety float that prevents water overfilling or spilling
- 5 years warranty on the control head and 10 years of warranty on the tanks
Cons
- Not ideal for household with large family members
Our Verdict
The Fleck 5600 SXT water softener is a decent choice if you have a medium-sized family with up to 6 members. The advanced water softening technology can treat and soften hard water of various grades. The system ensures there is no water wastage and will efficiently serve the water needs of your family. Moreover, the company offers an extensive warranty on this product which further adds to its value.
Fleck 9100 SXT Water Softener
Features Highlights
- Digital LCD Screen for monitoring salt intake,
- Continuous performance for 48 hours,
- High filtering capacity,
- High flow rate,
- Meter-based water regeneration,
- Easy to install,
- Maintenance-free.
Product Specification
-
Dimensions:
13 x 13 x 65 inches
-
Weight:
95 pounds
-
Grain Capacities:
80,000
-
Flow Rate:
22 Gallons per minute
-
Voltage:
24 volts
-
Number of People:
10 to 12 people
The 9100 SXT model efficiently supplies soft water to a larger household without interruption. The twin tank system makes sure this model performs optimally. The machine consumes less electricity and also ensures minimal water wastage. However, it is quite expensive but is definitely worth every penny.
Meter-based Water Regeneration
The 9100 SXT model is capable of filtering 40,000 grains of hard minerals in a single tank. It regenerates only after the tank reaches its full capacity. It records the amount of water used and activates the regeneration cycle accordingly. This feature minimizes water wastage and makes sure your household is always supplied with soft water.
Twin Tanks for Continuous Soft Water Supply
One main benefit of the 9100 SXT is the twin tanks that allow you to process water from one tank while the other tank is regenerating. Simultaneous processing and regeneration are not possible in water softeners with a single tank.
Backup Power Capacitor
The 9100 SXT runs continuously for 48 hours even when there is a power failure. The system keeps track of the water usage in the household and continues the regeneration cycle accordingly.
High Flow Rate
Fleck 9100 SXT has a flow rate of 22 gallons per minute. This rate is more than enough to supply a household with four bathrooms and even a small business. Most customers prefer the 9100 SXT for commercial purposes rather than household use.
Eco-Friendly
This model consumes very less electricity than other water softeners so that you save energy as well as money. Moreover, metered-based technology assures minimal water wastage and high efficiency.
High Filtering Capacity
Each tank of the 9100 SXT has a capacity to filter 40,000 grains of hard minerals. This makes it a total of 80,000-grain capacity system. This feature makes sure that your household is always served with soft water. Moreover, you can process water as well as continue regeneration simultaneously.
Easy Installation Steps
You don’t need to call for professional help for installing the water softener, although you can keep it as an option. Installing the twin tank is similar to installing a single-tank water softener. Just follow the guide that comes along with the product.
Pros
- Twin tank for water processing and regeneration simultaneously
- High flow rate and filtering capacity
- Can be used for large households and even for commercial use
Cons
- Expensive than other models
Our Verdict
If you have a larger household with up to 4 bathrooms or need a water softener for commercial purposes, the 9100 SXT is the best option for you. On our list, this water softener has the highest filtering capacity between water regeneration.
In addition to this, high water flow and twin tanks for alternating regeneration make this product effective for continuous soft water supply. Moreover, a 5-year warranty on the valve and a 10-year warranty on both the tanks are additional benefits to buy the 9100 SXT.
GE GXSF30V Water Softener
Features Highlights
- Durable design,
- Meter-based water regeneration,
- Automatic flush,
- High performance,
- Easy to install.
Product Specification
-
Dimensions:
22.5 x 14.4 x 43.2 inches
-
Weight:
80 pounds
-
Grain Capacities:
30, 400 grains
-
Flow Rate:
7.5 Gallons per minute
-
Water Consumption:
35.5 gallons of water in two hours of regeneration time
-
Number of People:
Maximum up to 3
The GE GXSF30V is an affordable water softener that is capable of softening the hardness of water like any high-tech water softener in the market. However, due to the limited flow rate, this water softener is best suited for a household with up to 3 members.
Automatic Flush
The GE GXSF30V features a control head that keeps track of water used daily and predicts the future need for soft water in the house. Based on this reading, the system feeds the salt into the resin tank and automatically flushes it.
Meter-based Regeneration
The GXSF30V system calculates the amount of water consumption in the house. And based on the parameter, the system automatically changes its settings to meet the demand for water needs. This metered-based regeneration also predicts the future soft water need of the house and adjusts the system configuration.
Digital Display
You can check the system’s performance status in the digital display. You can keep track of daily water consumption, the time left before regeneration, and the water flow rate. And whenever the machine is low on salt, the display beeps as a warning. The beeping continues until you refill the salt tank and reset the settings.
Meter-based Water Regeneration
GE GXSF30V model keeps track of the amount of water used and activates the regeneration cycle accordingly. This technology helps to minimize water wastage.
Effective Performance
This product serves small households efficiently and we must acknowledge that it does an excellent job. The 7.5 gallons per minute flow rate is enough for a family of three. The GXSF30V system removes up to 95 grains of hard minerals per gallon of water and has a capacity of 30,400 grain capacity per regeneration cycle. Finally, the system is capable of removing 7ppm of iron per gallon of water which makes this product an excellent mid-end water softener.
Effortless Installation
The product includes a guide on how to install the water softener. Anyone with a bit of experience in plumbing can easily install the product. You can hire a plumber if you have any difficulty while installing the system.
Durability
GE brand provides a 1-year warranty on all the parts of GXSF30V. The warranty further extends to 3 years for electronic monitor and 10 years for brine and resin tank.
Pros
- The digital control head enables quick and easy installation
- Metered- based regeneration
- Easy installation steps
- Low maintenance cost
- NSF certified
- Removes 7ppm of the iron particle from the water
Cons
- Not suitable for bigger households
- Has a limitation in use with a maximum of 1-inch pipe
Our Verdict
If you live in a small household with a maximum of three members, then the GE GXSF30V water softener is the one for you. This product comes at an affordable price and delivers optimum performance. The features in the GXSF30V along with its high-quality build should serve you soft water efficiently for years.
GE GXSH40V Water Softener
Features Highlights
- Durable design,
- High flow rate,
- Meter-based water regeneration,
- Automatic flush,
- High performance,
- Easy to install,
- NSF and CSA certified product.
Product Specification
-
Dimensions:
0.1 x 50 x 26 inches
-
Weight:
100 pounds
-
Grain Capacities:
40,200 grains
-
Flow Rate:
9.5 Gallons per minute
-
Water Consumption:
35.5 gallons of water in two hours of regeneration time
-
Number of People:
Maximum of 5
GE has designed the GXSH40V water softener to suit a household with up to 5 members. The compact design offers the capacity of 95 grains per gallon hardness removal so that your household is never in shortage of soft water. Moreover, with automatic technology and easy installation steps, the GXSH40V is very effective and efficient at what it does.
Intelligent Water Regeneration
The GXSH40V model can filter up to 40,200 grains of hard minerals in a single tank. It initiates the water regeneration process only after the tank reaches its filtering limit. The system keeps track of the amount of water used and activates the regeneration cycle so that water wastage is minimal and the use is optimal.
NSF and CSA certified
The GXSH40V water softener is an NSF and CSA certified product. This means the water softener assures:
- Material safety
- Accuracy in the brine system
- Standard pressure drop
- Standard water softening
- Wholesome structure
Therefore you can put your trust into this water softener as a decent machine for your household.
High Flow Rate
The flow rate in the GE GXSH40V is 9.5 gallons per minute which should be enough to supply a household of five members. You won’t notice pressure drop even when multiple outlets are on. Moreover, this model consumes very less electricity so that you save energy as well as money.
High Performance
This product supplies soft water to a medium-sized household without any interruption. The GXSH40V system removes up to 10ppm of iron per gallon of water and has a capacity of 40,000 grain capacity per regeneration cycle. Further, this model consumes salt at the rate of 5,080 grains per pound of salt.
In addition, the SmartSoft technology tracks the pattern of water usage of your household and modifies its settings to provide a continuous supply of soft water. This technology also optimizes the system for better performance and high water output. The GE blending valve allows you to customize the system settings for getting the exact level of water softness as you require.
Durability
Like the GXSF30V model, the GXSH40V also has a 1-year warranty on all the parts of GXSF30V. The warranty is further added to 3 years of electronic monitor and 10 years for brine and resin tank.
Pros
- Easy to install and use
- Metered-based water regeneration to minimize wastage
- SmartSoft technology learns the water usage pattern and provides continuous soft water supply
- Low maintenance cost
- NSF and CSA certified
- Removes 125 grains of hardness per gallon
Cons
- Lower iron removal capacity
- Not suitable for larger households
Our Verdict
The GE GXSH40V is an effective water softener that comes at a reasonable price. It is easy to install and anyone can operate it without any difficulty. If you have a medium family of up to 5 members, the GXSH40V is just the product for your soft water needs.
Comparison Table of Fleck Vs. GE Water Softeners
| SN | Model | Dimensions | Weight | Flow Rate | Tank | Grain Capacity | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Fleck 5600 SXT | 27 x 17 x 62 inches | 20.8 pounds | 12 Gallons per minute | Single | 48,000 grains | 5 Years for control head 10 Years for tanks |
| 2 | Fleck 9100 SXT | 13 x 13 x 65 inches | 95 pounds | 22 Gallons per minute | Twin-Alternating | 80,000 grains | 5-Years for the Valve and Electronics/ / lifetime on tanks |
| 3 | GE GXSF30V | 22.5 x 14.4 x 43.2 inches | 80 pounds | 7.5 Gallons per minute | Single | 30,100 grains | 1 year for all system parts 3 years for electronic monitor 10 years for brine and resin tank |
| 4 | GE GXSH40V | 0.1 x | 100 pounds | 9.5 Gallons per minute | Single | 40,200 grains | 1 year for all system parts 3 years -for electronic monitor 10 years for brine and resin tank |
Why Do We Need Water Softener?
The main purpose of using a water softener is to remove the hard minerals from water such as calcium, magnesium, and iron among others and make it soft. Water supply in the city area generally contains hard minerals so it is necessary to soften the water before you use it.
But why is hard water so bad?
Here are the reasons:
Consuming hard water can lead to many health issues in the long run. Other problems hard water can cause are:
- It leaves a stain on your dishes and faucets
- It makes your skin dry and itchy due to its corrosive nature
- Deteriorates water-infrastructure of your household
- Causes rusting of water pipes
- Leaves spots on your clothes
Now that we have acquainted you with the problems of hard water, we will talk about the benefits of a water softener.
Benefits of Water Softening System
- Your skin and hair will be healthy as the soft water treats your skin gently.
- Appliances that use water will function optimally
- Efficient energy use
- Minimal water wastage
How to Pick Right Water Softener for Your Household?
This section includes tips on how you can choose a water softener. These insights will definitely help you choose a model that best fits your household water needs.
1. Figure out Your Needs
First of all, you must figure out two things before considering any water softener:
- The hardness of water supply in your house and
- The maximum water use in your house daily
Determining these two factors will help you make an outline of the features in a water softener that fits the needs of your household. It will help to narrow down the options when you finally decide to get one for you.
2. Budget
Water softeners come in varying price ranges starting from 300 hundred dollars to more than 4 thousand dollars. You must first figure out your household needs, set your budget, and then search for the water softener that comes under that budget.
3. Capacity
The capacity of a water softener means how many grains of water hardness can it remove before regenerating. It may range from 8,000 up to 80,000 grains. Know one thing that more the capacity of the water softener, the better it will perform in softening the hard water.
4. Flow Rate
Flow rate means the amount of water that the machine can supply per minute. In other words, it is gallons per minute. We have included the GE models with flow rates ranging from 7.5 GPM to 22 GPM. These rates should be enough for small households.
More precisely, buy a water softener that can supply 2 gallons per minute flow rate per individual of the household. For example, 8 GPM for a family of 4, 20 GPM for a family of 10, and so on.
5. Metered Vs. Time-Based Water Regeneration
Most of the water softeners nowadays are equipped with metered regeneration technology. This technology allows the electronic sensors in the system to detect the daily water use of the household and regenerate accordingly. So if the water use increases, the regeneration speeds up and vice versa. Whereas, the time-based regeneration means that the regeneration starts based on the time clock regardless of the water consumption.
So if you ask us, Metered Regeneration technology is very practical as compared to time-based regeneration.
6. Certification
Finally, make sure that the product you choose is NSF/ANSI or WQA certified. These certifications mean that it is a quality product based on built and performance. Further, they also guarantee the following points:
- Material safety
- Accuracy in the brine system
- Standard pressure drop
- Standard water softening
- Wholesome structure
Frequently Asked Questions
Water softener starts developing resins coated with hardening particles over time. The machine undergoes a regeneration cycle where the salt in the brine tank mixes with the incoming water to remove the resins. When the cycle completes, the system starts softening the water again.
An American multinational company, General Electric (GE), manufactures all the GE products.
Pentair Residential Filtration LLC. produces Fleck water softeners.
Fleck and GE are quality water softener manufacturers and are NSF/ANSI certified brands. Without any doubt, their water softeners will last for many years. And to add to your benefit, they have provided a substantial warranty of 10 years on their products.
No, it is not a good idea. Connecting the water softener to the water heating system can cause the water softener to malfunction or even destroy the system.
Conclusion
Both Fleck and GE water softeners are great brands and rivals when it comes to the water-grade system. We can assure you that no matter whichever brand you choose, you will not be disappointed. Both brands manufacture quality water softeners that deliver optimum performance and have effective features to supply you with soft water. Make a list of your household needs and make sure the model you choose meets them. Let the water softener take care of the rest.
